The Farnese Hercules statue, a Roman copy of the Greek Herakles at rest
|

Josephus Wrote About Hercules. Does That Mean His References to Jesus Are Worthless?

Josephus wrote about Hercules. That fact occasionally gets raised in discussions about the historical Jesus, usually with a straightforward argument behind it. Hercules is a mythological figure, yet Josephus included him in a work presented as history. If Josephus could write about Hercules, why should anyone treat his references to Jesus as evidence that Jesus existed?

The objection deserves an answer because its underlying observation is correct. Ancient historians drew on legends, religious traditions, and inherited accounts that we would not accept uncritically today. Josephus was no exception.

What Josephus Actually Wrote About Hercules

In Antiquities of the Jews 1.240–241, Josephus is discussing Abraham's descendants through Keturah when he introduces material from Alexander Polyhistor, who in turn cites a writer named Cleodemus Malchus. According to that account, descendants of Abraham accompanied Hercules on a campaign against Libya and Antaeus. Hercules then married the daughter of one of those descendants and fathered a son. The story places the familiar Greek hero inside a purported history of Abraham's family.

Josephus introduces Alexander as a witness supporting what he has been saying. He gives this tradition a role in his historical argument, without warning the reader that the Hercules material is fictional. We need not claim that Josephus personally believed every detail to recognize what he is doing with the account. He is willing to use a tradition involving a legendary figure as supporting historical testimony.

There is sometimes an attempt to explain away the Hercules reference by pointing out that Josephus wrote about the worship of Hercules. He certainly did. In Antiquities 8.144–146, for example, he includes a report about a temple of Hercules at Tyre. But that is a different passage. In Book 1, Hercules takes part in a supposed ancestral history, and the criticism of Josephus is stronger because of it.

Josephus Was Not a Consistent Skeptic

It might be tempting to separate Josephus's early material about ancient ancestors from his accounts of later political events, treating the former as legendary and the latter as reliable history. His writing doesl not support such a clean division. The sources and subject matter change as Antiquities moves toward the Hellenistic and Roman periods, but extraordinary traditions do not disappear from his work.

In Jewish War 6.288–299, Josephus recounts a series of portents before Jerusalem's destruction in 70 AD. Among them are armed troops and chariots supposedly seen in the clouds. He acknowledges that the report sounds unbelievable, then appeals to those who claimed to have witnessed it and to the catastrophe that followed. His interpretation of the recent past was deeply shaped by divine providence and prophecy. Josephus could be writing about events close to his own lifetime and still give extraordinary reports a place in his explanation of history.

That complicates any simple appeal to his reputation as an eyewitness or contemporary. His proximity to events could give him information worth considering, while his understanding of those events could still be shaped by beliefs and traditions that require separate scrutiny.

Other Religious Figures in First-Century Judea

We can see the problem more clearly in Josephus's accounts of other religious figures. In Antiquities 18.116–119, he describes John the Baptist, his followers, and his execution by Herod Antipas. Josephus also reports that some Jews interpreted a later military defeat of Herod as divine punishment for John's death. That interpretation tells us something about how people understood the event, even if we have no reason to adopt it as a historical explanation for the defeat.

Another example is Theudas. According to Antiquities 20.97–99, he persuaded followers to accompany him to the Jordan River by promising that he would divide its waters. Roman forces intervened, and Theudas was captured and executed.

Josephus also describes Jesus son of Ananus in Jewish War 6.300–309, a man who repeatedly warned of Jerusalem's destruction and died during the siege. Josephus tells the story with the catastrophe already in view, making it reasonable to ask how that hindsight shaped the narrative.

The Two References to Jesus

Josephus's better-known reference to Jesus appears in Antiquities 18.63–64. Usually called the Testimonium Flavianum, it describes Jesus as a wise man, associates him with extraordinary deeds, and reports his execution under Pontius Pilate. The surviving wording also contains statements about Jesus that sound distinctly Christian, including language concerning his identity and his appearance after death.

That has made the passage one of the most disputed pieces of evidence in the discussion. Scholars have defended versions of three broad possibilities: that Josephus wrote the passage substantially as transmitted, that a Josephan account was altered by Christian copyists, or that the passage was inserted in its entirety. Each position has arguments that must be assessed from the text and its transmission.

The second reference appears in Antiquities 20.200, in an account of the high priest Ananus. After the death of the Roman governor Festus and before his successor arrived, Ananus convened a council and had James and several others condemned and stoned. The decision provoked objections and contributed to Ananus losing his office. In identifying James, Josephus uses the phrase "the brother of Jesus, who was called Christ." Jesus is mentioned to identify James, and the wording "called Christ" reports a designation without itself affirming that Jesus was the Messiah.

The James Passage: Authenticity and Transmission

Most scholars accept the James identification as authentic, and it has a stronger claim to authenticity than the surviving wording of the Testimonium Flavianum. It appears in all three principal surviving Greek manuscripts of Antiquities Book 20 and in a sixth-century Latin translation. Eusebius also quotes the passage, and later authors preserve it. The textual evidence is substantial, although the survival of a reading in our manuscripts does not, by itself, rule out an alteration that predates them. T. C. Schmidt makes a detailed case for authenticity in Appendix 2 of Josephus and Jesus (2025), drawing on both the manuscript witnesses and the surrounding narrative.

There is, however, a complication in the early Christian reception of Josephus. Origen, writing in the third century, attributes to him the claim that Jerusalem was destroyed as punishment for the death of James. No such statement appears in our surviving text of Josephus. Eusebius later passes along a similar attribution while also quoting the shorter account of James in Book 20.

The Book 20 reference has sometimes been used to support the existence of an earlier reference to Jesus in Book 18: perhaps Josephus expected his readers to recognize the name because he had already introduced him. That is possible, but Book 20 does not require the reader to have encountered Jesus earlier.

Is Josephus an Independent Witness?

Even if Josephus wrote the reference to James, another question remains: where did he obtain his information? He may have heard about Jesus and James from Christians, other Judeans, or several different sources. The surviving passage does not identify his informant.

Paul provides an earlier point of comparison. In Galatians 1:19, he says he met James, "the brother of the Lord." The most natural reading is that Paul meant a familial relationship, though alternative interpretations have been argued. If Josephus learned of James independently of Christians, his identification would add a separate line of evidence for the same relationship. If he drew on Christian reporting, its value as independent confirmation would be more limited.

What the Hercules Argument Actually Proves

The Hercules example should not be dismissed. Josephus did more than note that people worshiped a Greek hero; he used a story involving that hero as testimony within an account of Abraham's descendants. Anyone appealing to Josephus as a historical source should be prepared to acknowledge that weakness in his method.

But the Hercules passage leaves the central questions about Jesus where they were. It cannot tell us whether Christian scribes altered the Testimonium Flavianum, whether Josephus wrote the identification of James, or how he obtained information about either man. We have to answer those questions from the surviving texts and their history. Josephus's willingness to transmit legend is a reason to scrutinize him closely. It is not evidence that every figure he mentioned was a legend too.

Sources and Further Reading

  • Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews 1.240–241; 8.144–146; 18.63–64; 18.116–119; 20.97–99; 20.200–203.
  • Josephus, Jewish War 6.288–309.
  • Paul, Galatians 1:18–19.
  • Origen, Against Celsus 1.47 and 2.13; Commentary on Matthew 10.17.
  • Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 2.23.
  • Richard Carrier, "Origen, Eusebius, and the Accidental Interpolation in Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 20.200," Journal of Early Christian Studies 20, no. 4 (2012): 489–514.
  • T. C. Schmidt, Josephus and Jesus: New Evidence for the One Called Christ (Oxford University Press, 2025), Appendix 2, pp. 231–248.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply