Did King David Love Jonathan More Than His Wives?
After King Saul and his son Jonathan were killed fighting the Philistines, David composed a lament for them. He praised their courage and mourned Israel’s defeat, but when he turned specifically to Jonathan, the language became strikingly personal. Jonathan had been dear to him, David said, and his love had been extraordinary; greater even than the love of women.
In 2 Samuel 1:26, the King James Version reads:
“I am distressed for thee, my brother Jonathan: very pleasant hast thou been unto me: thy love to me was wonderful, passing the love of women.”
Was David saying that he loved Jonathan more than he loved his wives? Did their relationship involve romantic attraction, or was this an expression of deep friendship? The language is intimate enough to invite the question, although the passage does not explicitly describe a sexual relationship. Before deciding what David meant, we need to look at the Hebrew and the story leading up to his lament.
A Relationship That Threatened a Kingdom
The relationship begins in 1 Samuel 18, when David has emerged as a successful warrior in Saul’s service. Jonathan, Saul’s son and a potential successor to the throne, becomes deeply attached to him. The narrator says that Jonathan’s soul was bound to David’s soul and that Jonathan loved David as himself (1 Samuel 18:1). Jonathan then makes a covenant with David and gives him his robe, armor, sword, bow, and belt.
Those gifts have implications beyond an ordinary exchange between friends. Jonathan belongs to the royal household, and his possessions signal his status. As David’s popularity grows, Saul comes to regard him as a threat. Jonathan finds himself defending the very man who could replace his father’s dynasty.
Saul understands the danger. In 1 Samuel 20:30–31, he confronts Jonathan and warns him that David’s survival threatens Jonathan’s position. Jonathan nevertheless protects David. Later, in 1 Samuel 23:17, he acknowledges that David will become king and that he himself will stand second to him. The king’s son supports the man who will inherit the kingdom instead of him.
Ancient Near Eastern political relationships could be described using the language of love, particularly when rulers or allies pledged loyalty to one another. Jonathan’s covenant with David therefore had political consequences, but his support came at considerable personal risk. The narrative repeatedly describes his affection and his concern for David’s survival.
What Did Love Mean in Ancient Israel?
The Hebrew verb ahav, “to love,” and its related noun ahavah appear in several settings. Genesis 29:18 uses the verb for Jacob’s love of Rachel. Elsewhere, the same root describes family affection, friendship, or allegiance. The Hebrew Bible even says that Hiram of Tyre had loved David (1 Kings 5:1), a statement generally understood in connection with their political relationship. The word alone cannot tell us what kind of love is being described.
In 1 Samuel 20, Jonathan confirms that Saul intends to kill David, and the two men meet privately before David flees. They kiss one another and weep, with the account emphasizing David’s distress (1 Samuel 20:41). Some readers see romantic intimacy in this scene. Yet biblical accounts also describe men kissing as an expression of reconciliation or family affection. Esau kisses Jacob when they reconcile (Genesis 33:4), and Joseph kisses his brothers while weeping (Genesis 45:15).
What Does “Surpassing the Love of Women” Mean?
David’s words in 2 Samuel 1:26 include the Hebrew expression nifle’atah ahavatkha li me’ahavat nashim, usually translated along the lines of “your love to me was wonderful, surpassing the love of women.” The conventional translation makes Jonathan the one giving love and David its recipient. David would then be praising the love Jonathan showed him, rather than directly ranking his own affection for Jonathan against his affection for his wives.
The grammar allows for some uncertainty. The Hebrew word rendered “your love” can refer to love expressed by Jonathan or love directed toward him. The following li, “to me” or “for me,” also figures in how the phrase is understood. Walter Dietrich notes that the verse can be read as a comparison involving David’s love for Jonathan. The familiar English rendering is natural, but another reading can make David’s own feelings more prominent.
The phrase “love of women” is ambiguous as well. Women might be the people giving love, or they might be its objects. The Hebrew nashim can mean women generally or wives in a particular context. David might be comparing Jonathan’s devotion with the love women gave him, or comparing love for Jonathan with love for women. Those possibilities lead to different answers to our original question.
The disagreement predates modern debates about sexuality. The medieval commentator Radak records an interpretation associated with the Aramaic Targum that connects the comparison to David’s wives Abigail and Ahinoam. He also preserves an explanation attributed to his father, comparing Jonathan’s affection with the powerful love women show husbands or children.
The statement also belongs to a poem. In verse 24, David calls on the daughters of Israel to mourn Saul, recalling how Saul had adorned them. Two verses later, he speaks of Jonathan and the love of women. The proximity may help explain the imagery without resolving its meaning. Elsewhere in the lament, Saul and Jonathan are described as swifter than eagles and stronger than lions. David’s comparison of love may likewise be heightened by grief, though that does not make the affection he describes any less real.
What About David’s Wives, and His Own Feelings?
David’s marriages complicate any attempt to treat the lament as a ranking of his relationships. The narrative explicitly says that Michal, Saul’s daughter, loved David (1 Samuel 18:20). She helps him escape Saul, is later given to another man, and is eventually returned to David. By 2 Samuel 6, their relationship has deteriorated. Abigail and Ahinoam were also David’s wives while Jonathan was alive, but the biblical writers generally describe David’s marriages in connection with family, succession, and political conflict. They give us much less about his affection for his wives than about Jonathan’s affection for him.
There is a similar unevenness in how David and Jonathan’s feelings are described. The narrator repeatedly says that Jonathan loved David, while direct statements about David’s love for Jonathan are comparatively scarce. Orly Keren argues that their relationship served both men’s interests, including Jonathan’s concern for his family’s future and David’s public standing. She even considers whether the lament served a calculated political purpose.
David certainly benefited from Jonathan’s support. But the narrative also describes him weeping at their farewell and grieving after Jonathan’s death. Political advantage may help explain the covenant and its consequences; it is harder to use it to account for every expression of affection in the story. Nor can the narrator’s greater attention to Jonathan’s feelings tell us everything David felt in return.
Were David and Jonathan Lovers?
Susan Ackerman, in When Heroes Love, compares David and Jonathan with Gilgamesh and Enkidu in Mesopotamian literature. Both stories portray intense bonds between male heroes and profound grief when one companion dies. Ackerman examines the possibility that the language of friendship and loyalty also carries erotic implications.
Yaron Peleg approaches the relationship through the narrative’s treatment of gender and kingship. He argues that Jonathan is increasingly portrayed in a feminized position relative to David, and that this contributes to the account of David’s rise at the expense of Saul’s dynasty. His argument concerns the literary presentation of the relationship, whether or not the historical men were sexually involved.
Dariusz Dziadosz reaches a different conclusion, reading the account as a powerful male friendship with political, theological, and emotional dimensions, but without sufficient evidence of sexual relations. The biblical writers never explicitly identify David and Jonathan as lovers or describe sexual activity between them.
We also need to distinguish the literary account from the private lives of the historical figures it portrays. The books of Samuel were not written as modern biographies, and an erotic suggestion in the narrative, if one was intended, would not establish what the men actually did. Modern categories such as gay, straight, and bisexual introduce another difficulty: they describe forms of sexual identity that do not map neatly onto ancient Israel. The account can be examined for romantic or sexual suggestion without assigning either man a modern identity.
So Did David Love Jonathan More Than His Wives?
On the conventional reading of 2 Samuel 1:26, David says that Jonathan’s love for him surpassed the love of women. Other defensible interpretations make David’s own love for Jonathan part of the comparison, while “women” need not refer specifically to his wives. The wording is unusually strong, but it does not give us a dependable ranking of everyone David loved. Samuel’s accounts of his marriages were written for different purposes and give us little basis for reconstructing his private affections.
Jonathan’s willingness to protect David and relinquish his claim to the throne, the grief of their farewell, and David’s lament all point to an exceptional bond. Romantic interpretations are possible, and the language should be allowed its full force. Yet the text gives us no clear evidence that the relationship was sexual. Calling it an ordinary friendship would understate the intimacy the story portrays; claiming to know that they were lovers would go further than the evidence permits.
Sources and Further Reading
Ackerman, Susan. When Heroes Love: The Ambiguity of Eros in the Stories of Gilgamesh and David. Columbia University Press, 2005. https://cup.columbia.edu/book/when-heroes-love/9780231507257/
Dietrich, Walter. “David, King of Love.” In King David in the Deuteronomistic History, chapter 13, pp. 359–379. https://bibleinterp.arizona.edu/sites/bibleinterp.arizona.edu/files/2026-01/Dietrich.pdf
Dziadosz, Dariusz. “The Brotherhood of David and Jonathan: The Picture of Male Friendship in 1 Sam 18–2 Sam 1.” Verbum Vitae 39, no. 1 (2021): 163–198. https://doi.org/10.31743/vv.9752
Harding, James E. “Jonathan and His Relationship with David.” In The Oxford Handbook of King David (2026), 162–180. https://doi.org/10.1093/9780197652749.003.0014
Keren, Orly. “David and Jonathan: A Case of Unconditional Love?” Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 37, no. 1 (2012): 3–23. https://doi.org/10.1177/0309089212455544
Olyan, Saul M. “Surpassing the Love of Women: Another Look at 2 Samuel 1:26 and the Relationship of David and Jonathan.” In Authorizing Marriage? (2009), 7–16. https://doi.org/10.1515/9781400827138.7
Peleg, Yaron. “Love at First Sight? David, Jonathan, and the Biblical Politics of Gender.” Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 30, no. 2 (2005): 171–189. https://doi.org/10.1177/0309089205060606
Radak on 2 Samuel 1:26, with traditional Jewish interpretations collected at Sefaria. https://www.sefaria.org/Sheet.71393
Primary biblical passages: 1 Samuel 18–20; 23; 25; 2 Samuel 1; 3; 6; 9; Genesis 33:4; 45:15; 1 Kings 5:1.