Who Wrote the Book of Hebrews?
The mystery behind an anonymous New Testament book
Sometime in the early third century AD, the Christian scholar Origen considered a question that was already producing different answers. Who wrote the Epistle to the Hebrews?
The document was hardly obscure. Its author presented Jesus as a heavenly high priest and developed an elaborate argument about sacrifice, covenant, and the Jewish Scriptures. Hebrews was also associated with Paul, whose letters were becoming central to Christian teaching. Yet the work never names Paul—or anyone else—as its author.
Origen noticed that its Greek differed from Paul's familiar letters. He nevertheless regarded its teaching as Pauline and knew of traditions that assigned its composition to Luke or Clement of Rome. When it came to the person who actually wrote the text, he acknowledged that the answer was uncertain. Nearly two thousand years later, that remains the case.
There is no shortage of candidates. Paul, Barnabas, Apollos, Luke, Clement, and Priscilla have all been proposed. With each one, we have to ask whether the evidence points to authorship or simply makes that person a possibility.
A Book That Does Not Name Its Author
Although traditionally called an epistle, Hebrews begins more like a sermon than a letter. Paul's correspondence generally identifies the sender and recipients. Hebrews opens instead with a carefully constructed statement about God's revelation through the prophets and through his Son.
The author proceeds through sustained interpretations of Scripture, repeatedly turning from theological argument to appeals for perseverance. Only near the end do we encounter familiar features of correspondence: a reference to Timothy, greetings, and the description of the work as a “word of exhortation” (Hebrews 13:22–24).
Even the traditional title, To the Hebrews, does not establish the identity of the original audience; the recipients are never named in an opening address. We can infer that the writer was educated, proficient in Greek, and deeply familiar with Jewish Scripture. Those qualities tell us something about the author's world, but not the author's name.
Why Christians Connected Hebrews to Paul
By around 200 AD, Hebrews was being copied within a collection of letters associated with Paul. Papyrus 46, among our earliest substantial witnesses to that collection, places Hebrews immediately after Romans and before 1 Corinthians. Its position shows how the work was being received in at least some Christian circles, but the manuscript was copied generations after Paul lived. Its arrangement tells us little about who originally composed the text.
Hebrews was probably known even earlier. The late-first-century work known as 1 Clement contains substantial similarities to Hebrews, particularly in its presentation of Christ and use of Scripture. Many scholars understand these as evidence that the author of 1 Clement knew Hebrews. If so, Hebrews was circulating by the end of the first century AD, although 1 Clement does not identify its writer.
Early Christians Disagreed
Clement of Alexandria, writing around the turn of the third century AD, supplied one explanation for the literary differences. As Eusebius reports, Clement believed Paul wrote Hebrews in Hebrew and Luke translated it into Greek. He also suggested Paul omitted his name because he was addressing Jewish Christians. The explanation preserves Pauline authorship, but neither the supposed Hebrew original nor the reason for anonymity can be independently demonstrated.
Around the same period, Tertullian in North Africa gave a different answer. In On Modesty 20, he identified Hebrews as a letter of Barnabas.
Origen knew still other explanations. According to Eusebius, he considered the thoughts worthy of Paul but recognized that the language and composition differed. He reported traditions naming Luke and Clement of Rome. For Origen, Pauline teaching did not necessarily mean that Paul himself had written the Greek prose.
These competing answers long predate modern biblical criticism. Origen's famous admission of uncertainty should not be mistaken for an outright rejection of every Pauline connection, either. His own writings regularly treated Hebrews as Pauline in an important sense.
Does Hebrews Sound Like Paul?
The Greek of Hebrews is unusually polished and carefully organized. Paul was capable of sophisticated argument, so it would be misleading to suggest that he could not write well. Nevertheless, the sustained rhetorical style of Hebrews differs from the undisputed Pauline letters. Ancient Greek readers already recognized the difference.
More revealing is Hebrews 2:3. The author describes the message of salvation as first proclaimed by the Lord and then confirmed to the community by those who heard him. Paul, by contrast, emphasizes in Galatians 1:11–12 that he did not receive his gospel through human instruction but through revelation from Jesus Christ.
The two passages are not necessarily contradictory. Having a message confirmed by earlier witnesses is not identical to receiving it from them in the first place. Paul also describes contact with the Jerusalem apostles. Even so, the author of Hebrews seems comfortable speaking as a recipient of testimony from earlier witnesses, which is not Paul's customary way of presenting his authority.
Hebrews also devotes sustained attention to subjects that are much less prominent in Paul's undisputed letters: Jesus as high priest, Melchizedek, the heavenly sanctuary, and the relationship between repeated sacrifices and Christ's once-for-all offering. Different subjects do not establish different authorship, but taken together with the language and Hebrews 2:3, they make direct Pauline composition less likely.
Hebrews 13:23, meanwhile, refers to Timothy, a close associate of Paul. That is a genuine reason to consider a connection with Pauline circles, although Timothy's name does not identify the writer.
The Problem of a Hebrew Original
Clement of Alexandria's suggestion that Luke translated a Hebrew original encounters a further difficulty. Hebrews appears to develop some of its arguments directly from the Greek form of the Jewish Scriptures, commonly called the Septuagint. In Hebrews 10:5, for example, the author's quotation of Psalm 40 refers to a body being prepared, whereas the corresponding Hebrew wording speaks of ears being opened or dug.
Hebrews then uses that wording to develop its argument about Christ's bodily offering. A Hebrew original is not logically impossible, but it becomes harder to understand the surviving Greek as a straightforward translation of one. The work reads like a composition developed through close engagement with Greek Scripture.
Barnabas and the Other Candidates
Barnabas deserves particular attention because Tertullian actually names him. Acts identifies Barnabas as a Levite from Cyprus and a companion of Paul. Those details might fit a writer interested in priesthood and Jewish tradition, but a Levite did not automatically possess the specialized knowledge displayed in Hebrews. Nor do we have an authenticated writing by Barnabas to compare with it. Tertullian preserves an important tradition, but it does not settle the question.
Apollos has a different kind of appeal. Acts 18:24 describes him as an eloquent Alexandrian Jew well versed in Scripture. Those characteristics sound remarkably appropriate for Hebrews, and Martin Luther is commonly associated with proposing him as its author. Yet no surviving early testimony names Apollos, and no authenticated work of his survives for stylistic comparison. The biographical fit makes him a reasonable candidate, but gives us no direct link to the text.
Priscilla was an important participant in the early Christian movement. Acts portrays her and Aquila instructing Apollos, and Paul calls them coworkers. In 1900, Adolf von Harnack proposed that Priscilla might have composed Hebrews and that the writer's anonymity could reflect reluctance to circulate such a work under a woman's name. The proposal offers an explanation for the anonymity, but no ancient source attributes Hebrews to her, and we cannot establish that the writer's sex was the reason the name was omitted.
Luke and Clement of Rome at least appear in ancient authorship traditions. Luke's connection with Paul and literary ability make him conceivable, but the supposed translation from Hebrew is difficult to verify. Clement's writings resemble Hebrews, yet similarities may reflect Clement's use of an earlier document rather than common authorship. Neither proposal can be established.
Does the Date Help?
Hebrews is sometimes dated before 70 AD because it speaks of sacrifices in the present tense and never explicitly mentions the destruction of the Jerusalem Temple. A date before the destruction is possible, but neither observation proves that the Temple was still standing. The author repeatedly reasons from the scriptural tabernacle and its idealized worship, but present-tense description can serve a literary or theological purpose. Silence about the destruction is likewise not a reliable date by itself.
The text therefore allows for a date on either side of 70 AD. Even a firmer date would only narrow the historical setting in which the unknown writer worked.
What the Evidence Allows
The oldest surviving evidence shows that Hebrews circulated early and became associated with Paul's letters. Early Christians themselves offered different explanations for its origin. Its distinctive Greek, the perspective of Hebrews 2:3, and its sustained theological argument weigh against Paul personally composing the surviving text. None of those observations rules out every connection to the Pauline mission.
Barnabas has a meaningful ancient attribution. Luke and Clement also appear in early traditions. Apollos and Priscilla are plausible candidates proposed on other grounds. But none can be identified with confidence.
When Origen considered the question, he knew the traditions, recognized the unusual language, and could not name the composer with certainty. We have more manuscripts and more scholarship than he did, but we face the same essential limitation. Hebrews profoundly shaped Christian theology, particularly its understanding of Jesus' priesthood and sacrifice, even as the identity of the person who wrote it remains beyond our evidence.
Sources and Further Reading
Primary sources: Hebrews 2:3; 10:5; 13:22–24; Galatians 1:11–12; Acts 4:36; 18:24–26; Romans 16:3–4; 1 Clement 36; Tertullian, On Modesty 20; Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 3.38.1–3; 6.14.2–4; 6.25.11–14.
Studies: Harold W. Attridge, The Epistle to the Hebrews (1989); Craig R. Koester, Hebrews (2001); Luke Timothy Johnson, Hebrews (2006); Matthew J. Thomas, “Origen on Paul's Authorship of Hebrews,” New Testament Studies 65, no. 4 (2019): 598–609.