Gustave Doré engraving of Elijah and the prophets of Baal in 1 Kings 18
|

Can Christians Call People Names?

Mike Winger, Sean Feucht, and the Question of Righteous Mockery

Mike Winger recently received some pushback after using several mocking names for Sean Feucht, including “Sean the Fraud Feucht,” “Sean ‘someone get this on camera’ Feucht,” and “Sean Firebomb Feucht.” Winger’s response was that the objection seemed to be less about whether the accusations behind the names were true and more about whether a Christian should be using names like these in the first place.

To defend himself, Winger pointed to Scripture. Jesus called religious leaders hypocrites, blind fools, whitewashed tombs, snakes, and a brood of vipers. He referred to Herod as “that fox” and, in one of the more striking examples, turned to Peter and said, “Get behind me, Satan.” Winger also pointed to Elijah mocking the prophets of Baal, Paul mocking his opponents, and Jude’s description of false teachers as waterless clouds, fruitless trees, wild waves, and wandering stars.

His basic argument is that Christians have developed an idea of niceness that Scripture itself does not share. If Jesus, Elijah, Paul, and Jude could use this sort of language righteously, then simply pointing out that something is insulting or mocking does not establish that it is wrong. Winger went even further and said he was open to correction, but only if that correction would not also condemn the biblical authors.

I think Winger is largely correct on that point. Some try to get around these passages by arguing that Jesus was offering theological diagnoses rather than insults, or that he could speak this way because he was God. Neither answer really works. The language in Matthew 23 is theological and plainly derogatory, and Jesus is hardly the only biblical figure who speaks this way. Elijah mocks, Paul uses sarcasm and wordplay, and John the Baptist calls people a brood of vipers. Scripture presents a serious problem for the claim that righteous people never use insulting language.

The difficulty comes when we move from those biblical examples to Winger’s nicknames for Feucht. Scripture also repeatedly warns Christians about reviling, retaliation, careless speech, and how we correct our opponents. I wanted to know how those warnings fit with the passages Winger cites, and whether his particular examples stand up to the same scrutiny.

The Bible Really Does Use Insulting Language

Matthew 23 is probably the clearest place to begin. Jesus repeatedly calls the scribes and Pharisees “hypocrites.” He calls them “blind guides,” “blind fools,” and “blind Pharisees.” He compares them to whitewashed tombs that look beautiful on the outside while being full of dead bones and uncleanness within, and eventually calls them snakes and a brood of vipers.

“Whitewashed tomb” is an intentionally offensive comparison, even though Jesus is making a theological accusation. He explains it immediately: outwardly these leaders appear righteous while inwardly they are full of hypocrisy and lawlessness. The severity of the image communicates the severity of what he is accusing them of doing.

When Jesus tells Peter, “Get behind me, Satan,” he connects the rebuke to Peter’s conduct. Peter has become a stumbling block by setting his mind on human things rather than divine things. The designation is severe, and Jesus tells Peter exactly why he has used it.

Luke gives us another example when Jesus is warned that Herod wants to kill him. Jesus responds, “Go and tell that fox for me.” Scholars can debate the precise negative associations Jesus intended by calling Herod a fox, but there is little reason to turn the expression into something polite. Jesus deliberately applies an unflattering animal metaphor to an identifiable ruler.

The examples from Jesus are enough to complicate a blanket prohibition against insulting language. Other biblical figures make Winger’s case stronger still.

First Kings 18 explicitly tells us that Elijah mocked the prophets of Baal. When Baal fails to respond, Elijah suggests that perhaps their god is occupied, traveling, or asleep and needs to be awakened. The humor is part of the argument. A supposedly powerful god who is unavailable because he is traveling or sleeping is not much of a god.

Paul presents the same problem for anyone who wants to draw too clean a line between serious biblical rebuke and mocking rhetoric. He warns the Philippians about “dogs” and “evil workers” and turns the circumcision language of his opponents against them by referring to them as the “mutilation.” In Galatians, he goes considerably further, wishing that those agitating the churches over circumcision would go beyond circumcision and castrate themselves.

Paul’s remark is deliberately shocking wordplay. He had already spent much of Galatians explaining why he considered the circumcision controversy so serious. The remark adds a sharp rhetorical edge to a theological case he has already developed.

Scripture even occasionally plays with names. Abigail says of Nabal, “Nabal is his name, and folly is with him,” exploiting the association between his name and foolishness. Jeremiah goes further when, after Pashhur has him beaten and placed in stocks, he announces that the LORD will no longer call him Pashhur but Magor-missabib, “Terror on Every Side.” Hosea similarly uses Beth-aven in place of Bethel, turning the name itself into a theological criticism.

The examples differ in ways worth keeping in mind. Abigail plays on an existing name, Jeremiah’s renaming is presented as a divine judgment, and Hosea is speaking about a place rather than a person. Taken alongside Jesus, Elijah, and Paul, though, they make it difficult to argue that memorable, insulting, sarcastic, or mocking language is inherently outside the bounds of biblical speech. On that point, I think Winger is right.

Applying the Biblical Examples to Winger

I can agree with Winger about the biblical examples and still have questions about the names he chose. Paul publicly confronts Peter in Galatians because Peter’s conduct is affecting other Christians. That provides a precedent for public rebuke, but imagine that I attacked a pastor tomorrow and offered Paul’s confrontation of Peter as my defense. You would reasonably ask what the pastor had done, whether my accusation was accurate, what evidence supported it, and why public correction was warranted. You might also wonder whether I was trying to correct wrongdoing or settle a personal dispute.

Those are questions about the particular rebuke. Winger has established that a Christian can sometimes speak harshly, and I think he has made that case well. Whether his names for Feucht are justified depends on what he is accusing Feucht of doing and whether the evidence supports those accusations.

The Bible Also Tells Christians How to Treat Opponents

Alongside those examples of harsh rhetoric, Scripture gives Christians direct instructions about how to speak to others, including people they believe are wrong.

Paul tells Timothy that the Lord’s servant “must not be quarrelsome but kindly to everyone,” patiently enduring evil and correcting opponents with gentleness. He tells the Ephesians to avoid corrupt speech and to speak in ways that build others up. He tells Titus to avoid quarreling and show courtesy toward everyone. James warns at length about the destructive power of the tongue.

Paul says something remarkably similar about the apostles in 1 Corinthians. In the same letter in which he uses biting sarcasm, he says, “When reviled, we bless; when persecuted, we endure; when slandered, we speak kindly.” He expects Christians to show gentleness toward opponents, even as his own letters demonstrate that gentleness can sometimes coexist with severe rebuke. We have to account for both kinds of passages if we want to take the biblical teaching on speech seriously.

Christians Were Asking This Question Long Before Social Media

Augustine recognized that Christian love could sometimes require severity. In one place he refers to the “stern compassion of the righteous,” contrasting necessary correction with the sort of flattery that leaves someone in error. Elsewhere he warns about rebuking someone out of personal injury and the desire to hurt them in return. The reason for the rebuke mattered to him as much as its severity.

John Chrysostom makes the problem more complicated. At times he speaks strongly against reviling and insult, even asking, “What necessity…for insult?” Yet he also refuses to soften Paul’s command to “rebuke them sharply.” Some people, he argues, require severe correction, and sharp rebuke can coexist with meekness. He is concerned with how Christians correct people, including the anger and contempt that can accompany correction.

Thomas Aquinas comes remarkably close to asking Winger’s question directly. In his discussion of reviling, Aquinas has to deal with the biblical examples of language that sounds insulting. He distinguishes speech intended to dishonor someone from severe or even mocking words used toward legitimate correction. He explicitly allows that a mocking word can sometimes serve that purpose, while drawing on Augustine’s warning that invective requires care, necessity, and a legitimate end. Aquinas acknowledges the possibility of righteous mockery while treating the circumstances and intention behind it as morally significant.

Winger argued that the pushback he received concerned the appropriateness of his names rather than the truth of the accusations behind them. He takes that as evidence of a cultural objection. Yet the Christian tradition has long asked whether even a truthful accusation is being made for the right reasons and in an appropriate way.

The Westminster Larger Catechism makes the same point from a very different Christian tradition. It condemns scoffing, reviling, rash and harsh censuring, misconstruing another person’s intentions, unnecessarily aggravating faults, and even speaking truth maliciously or toward a wrong end. Yet the same catechism also condemns remaining silent when justice requires reproof or complaint.

The catechism leaves room for a person to be obligated to speak against wrongdoing while also holding that a truthful statement can be made maliciously. Augustine, Chrysostom, Aquinas, and the authors of the Westminster Larger Catechism approached the issue from different perspectives, but all recognized that the purpose and manner of correction deserved careful consideration. Winger’s critics would still need to show how his particular names fall short. They can, however, raise that question without abandoning Scripture.

What About Sean Feucht?

Winger’s three nicknames make different kinds of claims. I think they deserve to be considered separately, especially given the serious allegations surrounding Feucht and his ministry. Former associates have accused Feucht’s ministry of financial mismanagement, blurred boundaries between personal and ministry expenses, poor treatment of workers, and inadequate transparency. Those allegations have received independent reporting, and Feucht has denied wrongdoing. Winger is responding to a substantive controversy, although the allegations remain allegations unless the supporting evidence establishes them.

“Sean Firebomb Feucht”

Of Winger’s three examples, this one has the clearest factual referent. During a 2025 appearance in Montreal, a smoke bomb was set off inside the church during Feucht’s performance. Feucht subsequently said that two smoke bombs had been thrown at his head. Something real and potentially dangerous happened, and that deserves to be acknowledged.

Feucht also used the term “firebombed” to describe what happened, while police and subsequent reporting described the incident as involving a smoke bomb. Winger’s “Firebomb Feucht” nickname satirizes that difference in terminology. It is a joke with an identifiable point behind it, much as Elijah’s mockery draws attention to the failure of Baal to answer his prophets.

The question is how far the joke takes us. Feucht used “firebombed” for an incident described by police as involving a smoke bomb. Winger can fairly scrutinize that wording, although a conclusion that Feucht deliberately exaggerated the incident would require additional evidence. And anyone hearing the joke should come away understanding that a smoke bomb really was set off inside the church. I think this is Winger’s strongest example because its sting is closely connected to the substance of his criticism.

“Sean the Fraud Feucht”

“Fraud Feucht” is considerably more complicated because it makes a much broader claim. There are legitimate reasons to scrutinize Feucht’s ministry, including the allegations from former associates already mentioned. Feucht disputes those allegations.

In 2026, donor Steve Bray brought a lawsuit alleging fraud involving a $250,000 donation to Feucht’s ministry. On September 9, a federal judge dismissed the original complaint without prejudice because the allegations had not been pleaded with enough factual specificity. Bray filed an amended complaint on September 30, alleging that Feucht had solicited money for a 2023 tour that Turning Point USA had already agreed to finance. Feucht has denied wrongdoing and said the donated money was used for the tour.

The dismissal concerned the sufficiency of the original complaint, and the subsequent filing renewed the allegations under a more specific theory. The amended lawsuit is still an accusation, and the separate claims made by former associates remain unresolved. Anyone using the case to support a characterization of Feucht needs to account for both the ruling and the amended filing.

Of course, “fraud” also has an ordinary meaning. Someone might call a person a fraud to describe a phony, charlatan, or deceiver without making a legal accusation of financial fraud. Still, when someone is already facing financial allegations, readers may reasonably hear financial implications in the nickname. Calling a person a fraud also makes a broad judgment about that person’s character.

Scripture sometimes makes severe character judgments. Jesus calls people hypocrites, Paul calls people dogs and evil workers, and Acts records Paul calling Elymas a “son of the devil” and an “enemy of all righteousness.” The question becomes how well the evidence supports the breadth of the characterization.

Consider the progression from saying someone made an inaccurate statement to saying the person knowingly lied, repeatedly lies, or is a fraud. Each characterization reaches further, and the supporting evidence ought to reach further as well. Whether Winger has established enough to support “Fraud Feucht” is a question his biblical precedents alone cannot answer.

“Sean ‘Someone Get This on Camera’ Feucht”

This is the most difficult of the three for me to evaluate because I have not been able to establish the specific incident Winger was referring to.

The nickname appears to characterize Feucht as performative, suggesting that some of his public ministry or dramatic encounters are shaped by a desire to capture them on camera. Perhaps Winger has established that case elsewhere. Without knowing the factual basis for the phrase, I cannot tell whether he is summarizing a documented pattern or attributing a motive he cannot substantiate.

Claims about motivation are generally harder to establish than claims about observable behavior. We can see what someone records, posts, and says. A consistent pattern might give us grounds to draw reasonable conclusions about motivation, but we need to be careful when moving from a person’s actions to an explanation of why that person acted.

For now, I do not have enough information to judge whether the nickname is warranted. I would need to see what Winger was referring to before drawing a stronger conclusion.

Public Criticism and Harsh Language

Some of Winger’s critics may prefer that he address Feucht privately. That can be appropriate in some circumstances, although Scripture also contains public correction of public conduct. Paul confronts Peter when Peter’s behavior is affecting other believers. Jude warns a Christian community about people he considers dangerous, and Jesus publicly condemns religious leaders whose conduct affects others.

If Winger believes Feucht is misleading Christians, mishandling ministry resources, or exaggerating events through a public ministry, he has grounds to investigate and publicly criticize those concerns, provided the evidence supports them. In some circumstances, remaining silent could be irresponsible. The manner of criticism still deserves consideration, of course, but a demand for nicer language leaves much of the biblical evidence unanswered.

Paul chose to make the circumcision controversy memorable with a shocking remark about castration. Elijah mocked Baal for apparently being asleep, and Jesus compared religious leaders to tombs filled with dead bodies. Severe language can expose absurdity, make hypocrisy recognizable, or convey the gravity of an accusation. That gives Winger a serious defense of harsh rhetoric as a form of criticism. He still has to show that the particular severity of his own remarks serves the criticism he is making.

Correction and Retaliation

The warnings about retaliation offer another way of examining that purpose. First Peter says of Jesus that when he was abused, “he did not return abuse.” Peter then tells Christians to bless those who abuse them, and Paul similarly says, “When reviled, we bless.” These instructions come from the same biblical tradition that permits severe rebuke. Augustine’s warning about correction driven by personal injury, and Chrysostom’s concern about anger, help explain the kind of conduct the apostles were warning against.

Winger and Feucht have publicly criticized one another. I do not know Winger’s motives, and I am not going to pretend that I do. It would make little sense to argue that our judgments should stay within the evidence and then finish by reading Winger’s mind. Being personally attacked would not require him to stop criticizing Feucht, either. Sometimes public criticism invites personal attacks precisely because it exposes uncomfortable facts.

Still, once a dispute becomes personal, the purpose of our rhetoric deserves closer attention. Is it exposing wrongdoing, warning others, correcting error, or protecting people? Has some part of it shifted toward settling a personal score? I cannot answer those questions for Winger, but I think Scripture gives him good reason to ask them.

Proverbs 26 and the Problem of Wisdom

After working through these passages and the Christian tradition surrounding them, I keep coming back to two verses in Proverbs. They appear immediately beside each other:

“Do not answer fools according to their folly,

or you will be a fool yourself.”

And then:

“Answer fools according to their folly,

or they will be wise in their own eyes.”

Proverbs is not specifically giving instructions about satire or name-calling here, and I do not want to make the verses carry more than they were intended to. Yet they capture the need for judgment that runs through this discussion. Answering another person’s folly may expose it, or we may end up participating in it ourselves.

Christian history gives us plenty of reason to take that warning seriously. Catholics and Protestants during the Reformation could both appeal to the importance of truth and the danger of false teaching while using vicious rhetoric against one another. Each side could find biblical examples of harsh denunciation. The existence of those examples offered little assurance that their own rhetoric was warranted.

Where I Land

Winger challenged people to correct him without also condemning the biblical authors, and I think his challenge is fair. Scripture plainly allows room for severe rebuke and, at times, mockery. Jesus, Elijah, and Paul used language that could offend. We should be careful about declaring something sinful simply because we find it harsh.

After considering his nicknames, though, I find myself wondering whether being justified in saying something is always reason enough to say it. We can publicly investigate wrongdoing, expose misleading claims, and warn other Christians without softening the accusations. We can also choose our words with a little more care than the moment might demand. Especially when a disagreement has become personal, that choice is worth making.

I keep coming back to the idea that Christians are supposed to be a light to the world. I want that reflected in how we handle the people we disagree with, including those whose behavior genuinely warrants criticism. Taking the high road may involve refusing a satisfying insult, explaining the evidence, and trusting people to see the problem for themselves. A person can be right about the underlying criticism and still leave the audience wondering whether the mockery was necessary.

I certainly understand the temptation. A clever nickname can be satisfying, particularly when someone seems to be doing real harm. But I would like to see Christians show that we can do better. Proverbs gives us examples of the wisdom required both to answer a fool according to his folly and to hold back. Even where a mocking name might be defensible, choosing to leave it unsaid can be one way of showing the kind of Christianity we want people to see.

Sources and Further Reading

Biblical quotations are from the NRSVUE unless otherwise noted. Key passages include Matthew 16:23; Matthew 23:13–36; Luke 13:32; 1 Kings 18:27; Philippians 3:2; Galatians 5:12; 1 Corinthians 4:8–13; 2 Timothy 2:23–26; 1 Peter 2:23; 3:9; and Proverbs 26:4–5.

Augustine, Letter 33, especially §3. On correction and the “stern compassion of the righteous.”

John Chrysostom, Homily 2 on Titus. On rebuke, insult, and pastoral correction.

Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, Question 72. On reviling, corrective speech, and mocking words used toward correction.

Westminster Larger Catechism, Question 145. On reviling, harsh censuring, malicious use of truth, and undue silence in a just cause.

John Wesley, “The Cure of Evil-Speaking”. On truthful speech that can nevertheless be wrongful.

Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§2475–2479. On rash judgment, detraction, and calumny.

Associated Press investigation of allegations concerning Sean Feucht’s ministries and finances. Reports allegations by former associates and Feucht’s denials.

The Canadian Press / CityNews report on the July 2025 Montreal incident. Reports Montreal police’s description of a smoke bomb and Feucht’s account.

MinistryWatch report on the September 2026 dismissal of the Bray lawsuit. Reports dismissal without prejudice and permission to amend the complaint.

Associated Press report on Bray’s amended September 30, 2026, fraud complaint. Reports the renewed allegation and Feucht’s response.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply